Residence as Leverage: Economic Violence against ThirdCountry National Women and the Paths to SDG 5 in EU Law

  • Giuseppina Pizzolante Associate Professor of European Union Law, Ionian Department, University of Bari Aldo Moro, Taranto, Italy
Keywords: Economic violence; Istanbul Convention; derived residence rights; third-country national women; EU free movement law; SDG 5

Abstract

Economic violence is recognised as a form of domestic violence by Article 3 of the Istanbul Convention and by Directive (EU) 2024/1385. For third-country national women whose right of residence derives from a spouse or partner, it acquires a specific legal dimension: the perpetrator controls not only household resources but also the victim’s legal presence in the host State. This paper assesses whether European Union (EU) law and its national implementation address or reproduce this dependency, through a doctrinal analysis of EU law and case law and an illustrative analysis of Italian law. Under Directive 2004/38, as interpreted in NA and X, a victim retains her right of residence after the breakdown of the relationship only if she is economically active or self-sufficient: the very autonomy that economic abuse is designed to destroy. This economic conditionality is difficult to reconcile with Article 59 of the Istanbul Convention, which binds the Member States that have ratified it, although its reach for the EU in the field of free movement is doubtful. Member States can rely on Article 37 of Directive 2004/38 to grant more favourable protection. The Italian case shows that economic conditionality operates at more than one level: it reappears in the national rules on family permits, and the victim can escape it only through a national permit that turns a right into an authorisation subject to administrative appraisal. Women whose abuse was primarily economic are also the least likely to prove the danger that this permit requires, and its holders are excluded from the national income-support measure designed for victims. The paper concludes that an autonomous residence right free from economic conditions is a prerequisite for achieving SDG targets 5.2 and 5.a.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Adams, A. E., Sullivan, C. M., Bybee, D., & Greeson, M. R. (2008). Development of the Scale of Economic Abuse. Violence Against Women, 14(5), 563–588.

Bartiromo, M. M. (2025). Il riconoscimento della protezione internazionale alle donne esposte a discriminazioni e violenze di genere nella recente giurisprudenza della Corte di giustizia dell’Unione europea. Eurojus, (4), 218–249.

Briddick, C. (2020). Combatting or enabling domestic violence? Evaluating the residence rights of migrant victims of domestic violence in Europe. International and Comparative Law Quarterly, 69(4), 1013–1034.

Commissione parlamentare di inchiesta sul femminicidio, nonché su ogni forma di violenza di genere. (2026). Relazione sulla violenza economica di genere (Doc. XXIII, n. 17). Camera dei deputati – Senato della Repubblica.

Council of Europe. (2011). Explanatory report to the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence (Council of Europe Treaty Series No. 210).

Council of Europe Treaty Office. (2023). Reservations and declarations for Treaty No. 210: Cyprus, partial renewal of reservation (Note verbale of 15 March 2023, registered on 17 March 2023). Council of Europe.

De Vido, S. (2026). Il nuovo Patto europeo su migrazione e asilo alla luce della Convenzione di Istanbul del Consiglio d'Europa: verso l'incorporazione di una prospettiva sempre più sensibile al genere? Freedom, Security & Justice: European Legal Studies, (1), 210–234.

Di Stasi, A., Cadin, R., Iermano, A., & Zambrano, V. (Eds.). (2023). Donne migranti e violenza di genere nel contesto giuridico internazionale ed europeo / Migrant women and gender-based violence in the international and European legal framework. Editoriale Scientifica.

European Commission. (2014). Communication on guidance for application of Directive 2003/86/EC on the right to family reunification (COM(2014) 210 final).

European Institute for Gender Equality. (2026, June 2). Bringing economic violence into view: Better data for better action in the EU. https://eige.europa.eu/gender-statistics/dgs/data-talks/bringing-economic-violence-view-better-data-better-action-eu

Federal Office for Gender Equality. (2026). Violenza domestica nel contesto migratorio (Factsheet B5). Swiss Federal Department of Home Affairs. https://www.bfeg.admin.ch

Federal Republic of Germany. (2025). State report on the implementation of the Istanbul Convention: First thematic evaluation round (GREVIO/Inf(2025)16). Council of Europe.

Friedery, R. (2023). Migrant women in Germany: Challenges and protection. In A. Di Stasi, R. Cadin, A. Iermano, & V. Zambrano (Eds.), Donne migranti e violenza di genere nel contesto giuridico internazionale ed europeo (pp. 553–570). Editoriale Scientifica.

Genovese, D. (2018, February 5). Violenza di genere e protezione internazionale. Note a margine di un recente orientamento della Corte di cassazione. Questione Giustizia.

INPS. (2025). Circolare n. 54 del 5 marzo 2025: Reddito di Libertà. Istituto Nazionale della Previdenza Sociale.

INPS. (2026a). Circolare n. 44 del 9 aprile 2026: Incremento a 530 euro del contributo mensile del Reddito di Libertà; risorse disponibili per l’anno 2026. Istituto Nazionale della Previdenza Sociale.

INPS. (2026b). Circolare n. 58 del 20 maggio 2026: Assegno di inclusione. Istituto Nazionale della Previdenza Sociale.

Istat. (2015). La violenza contro le donne dentro e fuori la famiglia: Anno 2014. Istituto Nazionale di Statistica.

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2024, January). How do OECD countries respond to domestic violence against migrants? (Migration Policy Debates No. 34). OECD Publishing.

Pizzolante, G. (2024). Alcune riflessioni in tema di violenza domestica correlata alla libera circolazione e al diritto di soggiorno dei coniugi o dei partner extra UE. Freedom, Security & Justice: European Legal Studies, (2), 322–348.

Porchia, M. (2021). Dalla tutela della vulnerabilità al riconoscimento di un diritto per le donne migranti: la Convenzione del Consiglio d’Europa sulla prevenzione e la lotta contro la violenza nei confronti delle donne e la violenza domestica nella giurisprudenza nazionale. AG About Gender, 10(20), 64–93.

SCUDI – Scuola di diritti umani. (2025, February 26). L'art. 18 bis del Testo Unico Immigrazione "Permesso di soggiorno per le vittime di violenza domestica". Cittadinanzattiva. https://scudi.cittadinanzattiva.it/it/banca-dati-giuridica/lart-18-bis-del-testo-unico-immigrazione-permesso-di-soggiorno-per-le-vittime-di-violenza-domestica

State Secretariat for Migration. (2024). Änderung AIG und VZAE (21.504; Härtefallregelung bei häuslicher Gewalt). https://www.sem.admin.ch/sem/de/home/sem/rechtsetzung/archiv/aig-haeusliche-gewalt.html

Stoyanova, V. (2023). Article 59: Residence status. In S. De Vido & M. Frulli (Eds.), Preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence: A commentary on the Istanbul Convention (pp. 662–672). Edward Elgar.

Strumia, F. (2022). Speaking too little yet saying too much. The wrong signals about EU values: X. v Belgian State. Common Market Law Review, 59(4), 1195–1218.

United Nations General Assembly. (2015). Transforming our world: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (A/RES/70/1).

United Nations General Assembly. (2017). Work of the Statistical Commission pertaining to the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (A/RES/71/313).

Legal sources

Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women, 1249 UNTS 13 (1979).

Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings, CETS No. 197 (2005).

Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence, CETS No. 210 (2011).

Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, OJ C 202, 7 June 2016, Articles 20, 21 and 23.

Council Directive 2003/86/EC of 22 September 2003 on the right to family reunification.

Directive 2004/38/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the right of citizens of the Union and their family members to move and reside freely within the territory of the Member States.

Directive 2011/95/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 December 2011 on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals or stateless persons as beneficiaries of international protection (recast).

Directive 2012/29/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2012 establishing minimum standards on the rights, support and protection of victims of crime.

Directive (EU) 2024/1385 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 May 2024 on combating violence against women and domestic violence.

Regulation (EU) 2024/1347 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 May 2024 (Qualification Regulation).

Council Decisions (EU) 2023/1075 and (EU) 2023/1076 of 1 June 2023 on the conclusion of the Istanbul Convention by the European Union.

Case C-115/15, NA, EU:C:2016:487.

Case C-115/15, NA, Opinion of Advocate General Wathelet, EU:C:2016:259.

Case C-930/19, X v État belge, EU:C:2021:657.

Case C-621/21, Intervyuirasht organ na DAB pri MS (Femmes victimes de violences domestiques), EU:C:2024:47.

Case T-5/25, HD and Others v European Parliament and EEAS, order of 9 March 2026, EU:T:2026:192.

Case C-404/26, Duloff, request for a preliminary ruling lodged on 28 April 2026 (pending).

Opinion 1/19 (Istanbul Convention), EU:C:2021:832.

Case 170/84, Bilka-Kaufhaus v Weber von Hartz, EU:C:1986:204.

Case 267/83, Diatta v Land Berlin, EU:C:1985:67.

Case C-218/14, Singh and Others, EU:C:2015:476.

Case C-646/21, K and L, EU:C:2024:487.

Joined Cases C-608/22 and C-609/22, AH and FN, EU:C:2024:828.

Joined Cases C-175/08, C-176/08, C-178/08 and C-179/08, Abdulla and Others, EU:C:2010:105.

Case C-255/19, OA, EU:C:2021:36.

ECtHR, Airey v Ireland, no. 6289/73, 9 October 1979.

ECtHR (Grand Chamber), Kurt v Austria, no. 62903/15, 15 June 2021.

ECtHR, Opuz v Turkey, no. 33401/02, 9 June 2009.

ECtHR, Talpis v Italy, no. 41237/14, 2 March 2017.

Italy, Legislative Decree No. 30 of 6 February 2007 (transposing Directive 2004/38), Articles 3, 10, 17 and 23.

Italy, Legislative Decree No. 286 of 25 July 1998 (Consolidated Act on Immigration), Articles 1, 18-bis, 19 and 30.

Italy, Tribunale di Bari, Sezione immigrazione e protezione internazionale, decree of 18 January 2021, RG No. 38/2021 (Article 18-bis, Legislative Decree No. 286/1998).

Italy, Decree-Law No. 69 of 13 June 2023, converted with amendments by Law No. 103 of 10 August 2023, Article 18-ter.

Italy, Decree-Law No. 146/2025 (amendments to the “special cases” permits under Articles 18, 18-bis and 18-ter of the Consolidated Act).

Italy, Law No. 213 of 30 December 2023 (2024 Budget Law), Article 1(187).

Italy, Law No. 91 of 13 June 2025 (European Delegation Law 2024).

Switzerland, Federal Act on Foreign Nationals and Integration of 16 December 2005 (SR 142.20), Article 50.

Published
2026-11-20
How to Cite
Pizzolante, G. (2026). Residence as Leverage: Economic Violence against ThirdCountry National Women and the Paths to SDG 5 in EU Law. European Scientific Journal, ESJ, 59, 556. Retrieved from https://eujournal.org/index.php/esj/article/view/21780
Section
ESI Preprints